2019: SUNY Canton.
- President: David Valone (Quinnipiac)
2018: D’Youville College, Buffalo.
- President: Joseph Cope (SUNY Geneseo)
2017: St. Francis College, Brooklyn.
- President: Jeffrey Glodzik (D’Youville)
2016: University at Albany, SUNY.
- President: Eric Platt (St. Francis)
2015: St. John Fisher College, Rochester.
- President: Fred Dotolo (St. John Fisher)
2014: SUNY Geneseo.
- President: Timothy Thibodeau (Nazareth)
2013: Nazareth College, Rochester.
- President: Martin Ederer (Buffalo State)
2012: SUNY Oswego.
- President: Katherine Clark (SUNY Brockport)
2011: Canisius College, Buffalo.
2010: Siena College, Loudonville.
2009: SUNY Brockport.
- President: Fred Dotolo (St. John Fisher)
2008: Le Moyne College, Syracuse.
- President: Andrew Nicholls (Buffalo State)
2007: Niagara University, Lewiston.
- President: Julie Gibert (Canisius College)
2006: Hartwick College, Oneonta.
- President: Greta Butcher (United States Military Academy)
2005: United States Military Academy, West Point.
- President: Christopher Mack (SUNY Oswego)
2004: St. John Fisher College, Rochester.
- President: Dorinda Outram (Rochester)

L-R: Barbara Blaszak (Treasurer), Dave King (Immediate Past President), Dorinda Outram (President), Jim Valone (Secretary).
2003: SUNY Oswego.
- President: David King (Oswego)
2002: Canisius College, Buffalo.
- President: Jennifer M. Lloyd (Brockport)
2001: Hartwick College, Oneonta.
- President: Jonathan Dewald (Buffalo)
2000: Le Moyne College, Syracuse.
1999: SUNY Cortland.
1998: SUNY Geneseo.
1997: Le Moyne College, Syracuse.
1996: United States Military Academy, West Point.
- President: Lee Wyatt (United States Military Academy)
1995: St. John Fisher College, Rochester.
- President: Barbara Blaszak (Le Moyne)
1994: Cornell University, Ithaca.
- President: Alfred Kelly (Hamilton)
1993: University of Rochester.
- President: Larry Wallace (Hartwick)
1992: Le Moyne College, Syracuse.
- President: Larry Jones (Canisius)
1991: University at Albany, SUNY.
- President: Daniel S. White (Albany)
1990: SUNY Oswego.
- President: Orville Murphy (Buffalo)
1989: Niagara University, Lewiston.
- President: Frederick D. Marquardt (Syracuse)

1988: Hartwick College, Oneonta.
- President: Sandy Gutman (Cortland)
1987: SUNY Geneseo.
1986: Syracuse University.
- President: Thomas J. Schaeper (St. Bonaventure)
1985: SUNY Binghamton.
1984: SUNY Cortland.
1983: Canisius College, Buffalo / University at Buffalo.
1982: University at Albany, SUNY.
1981: St. Bonaventure University, Allegany.
- President: Sanford Elwitt (Rochester)
1980: University of Rochester.
- President: Susan Stuard (Brockport)
1979: Ithaca College.
- President: Harold Emery (Ithaca)
1978: SUNY Binghamton.
- President: Warren Wagar (Binghamton)
1977: Syracuse University.
- President: John Moody (Boston College)
1976: SUNY Oswego.
- President: L.A. Gebhard (Cortland)
1975: SUNY New Paltz.
1974: SUNY Cortland.
1973: Eisenhower College, Seneca Falls.
1972: SUNY Brockport.
- President: William Salomone (Rochester)
1971: Colgate University, Hamilton.
- President: William Askew (Colgate)
1970: Kirkland College, Clinton / Hamilton College, Geneva.
- President: Charles J. Adler (Hamilton)

1969: Marymount College, Tarrytown.
- President: Elisa Carillo (Marymount)
1968: University at Albany, SUNY.
- President: Matthew H. Elbow (Albany)
1967: Ithaca College.
- President: Robert A. Ryan (Ithaca)
1966: Buffalo State College.
- President: David A. Rogers (Buffalo State)
1965: Le Moyne College, Syracuse.
- President: John Bush, S.J. (Le Moyne)
1964: Cornell University, Ithaca.
1963: Hobart and William Smith Colleges, Geneva.
- President: Francis O’Loughlin (Hobart)
1962: Harpur College (now SUNY Binghamton)
- President: Sidney Harcave (Harpur)
1961: United States Military Academy, West Point.
- President: J.R.W. Gwynne-Timothy (Western Ontario)
1960: SUNY Cortland.
- President: Gilbert A. Cahill (Cortland)
1959: Cornell University, Ithaca.
- President: Edward Fox (Cornell)
1958: Syracuse University.
1957: University of Rochester.
1956: Colgate University, Hamilton.
1955: Wells College, Aurora.
1954: Hobart and William Smith Colleges, Geneva.
1953: Colgate University, Hamilton.
1952: Cornell University, Ithaca.
1951: Colgate University, Hamilton.